Troutnut.com Fly Fishing for Trout Home
User Password
or register.
Scientific name search:

> > Pinched-down barbs vs designed and manufactured barbless hooks?

Pinched-down barbs vs designed and manufactured barbless hooks?

By Troutnut on July 18th, 2019, 1:04 pm
Recently I've been fishing entirely with barbless flies, and I've pinched down the barbs on everything in my fly boxes. To some extent this is because I'm sure it helps a little bit with survival; the scientific research is mixed on whether this is a big enough difference to matter to whole populations, but I know I used to damage a fish once in a while because the barb made the hook hard to remove, and now I don't. However, my main motive is a form of laziness: I fish places that require barbless hooks sometimes, and it's easier to de-barb everything and err on the side of caution than to keep track of the rules about that.

I found an interesting blog post recently by John Newbury talking about barbless hooks for Czech nymphs and how retention wasn't very good on barbless hooks that were manufactured using the same designs as barbed hooks but minus the barbs. I assume the same reasoning would apply to pinched barbs, too. As an alternative, he suggested hooks designed for retention when fished barbless such as the Hanak 333 BL and Fulling Mill Czech Hook. I've never used either of those, but the recently-started Montana brand Firehole Sticks seems to use similar design principles and I have fished those with some success.

However, I haven't really had an opportunity to do a side-by-side comparison between those designed barbless hooks and de-barbed hooks using similar flies. I'm curious if anybody else here has done enough of that to form an opinion.

Comments / replies

RleePJuly 19th, 2019, 7:56 am
NW PA - Pennsylvania's Glacial Pothole Wonderland

Posts: 372
Interesting stuff, Jason... My relatively few experiences with hooks designed/manufactured with no barbs has been that I lose more fish due to lack of retention. I'm of the view that a pinched-down originally barbed hook is the best of both worlds and retains more fish without making a measurable difference in fish damage (as well as damage to my earlobes from errant casts) compared to fully barbless hooks. IMO, the "bump" matters and is a friend to both us and the fish..
TroutnutJuly 19th, 2019, 8:59 am
Administrator
Bellevue, WA

Posts: 2533
That is good food for thought!

as well as damage to my earlobes from errant casts


Ha, yeah I forgot to mention my one time extracting a hook that was in past the barb (not an errant cast, but a passing branch on a float trip that yanked things the wrong way) definitely made me lean more toward fishing barbless.
Jason Neuswanger, Ph.D.
Troutnut and salmonid ecologist
PartsmanJuly 19th, 2019, 3:02 pm
bancroft michigan

Posts: 227
Jason, so far my experience with barbless vs. pinched is about a wash, I have used the tiemco barbless dryfly black hook quite a lot and really like it, also the barbless nymph and jig hooks have been worked well. I do have a pretty big stash of barbed hooks and I always pinch the barbs, but once there gone I will be going all barbless.
Mike.
IasgairJuly 25th, 2019, 7:48 am
Colorado

Posts: 148
Jason, I have been using barbless hooks for years. I am sad and sorry to say I have deformed the faces of too many fish, and one is too many to begin with, in my early years with using hooks with barbs. No longer my friend.

Yes, you are 100% correct on how much easier it is to release a fish with barbless hooks, and yes, the losing of fish can become a higher percentage. But I look at it in a different way. Using barbless hooks makes it more sporting for me, and actually has helped me learn how to play a fish better.

As for Fire Hole Sticks, and the Partridge Patriot series, the point of the hook is beaked, which means it is slightly turned upward for more holding power, or better retention as you say.

The Tiemco 100SP-BL is a barbless hook that has the same design as the Tiemco 100 101 hooks, and rightly a fine sturdy hook, it lacks that holding power that the Fire Hole Sticks and Partridge Patriot series has.

Yes, pinching the barbs down leaving that slight bump helps, but say for example, in some waters here in Colorado, that do regulate barbless hooks, when the game wardens or Park Rangers check the hook, they use a cotton ball to swipe the hook where the barb was, and if there's any cotton left on that area of the hook, you'll be looking at a fine to pay. Here in Colorado, they are serious about no barbs.

I only use Fire Hole & Partridge now and I am very pleased with those products. Try them out, or any brand that has the beaked hook, and tell us what you think. If you lose your first fish, count it as a fluke. But like I said, using barbless has taught me to play fish better by being more patient and keeping tension on the line better.

Good luck.

Quick Reply

You have to be logged in to post on the forum. It's this easy:
Username:          Email:

Password:    Confirm Password:

I am at least 13 years old and agree to the rules.

Related Discussions

TitleRepliesLast Reply
Re: Should have known
In Beginner Help by Iasgair
24Mar 3, 2017
by Wbranch
Re: hooksets and barbless hooks...
In General Discussion by Roguerat
23Jun 27, 2018
by Iasgair
Re: Firehole Dry Fly hooks
In Fly Tying by Iasgair
5Mar 6, 2019
by Iasgair
Re: Biological Name of BWO
In Fly Tying by Feathers5
22Oct 30, 2013
by Oldredbarn
Re: Best Holding Hooks
In General Discussion by Martinlf
4May 15, 2012
by Martinlf
Re: filing vs. smashing
In Fly Tying by Mcjames
4May 3, 2009
by Wbranch
Re: To debarb or not to debarb
In Fly Tying by Martinlf
45May 14, 2012
by Entoman
Re: New here!
In General Discussion by Dwiltshire
22Nov 16, 2010
by Keystoner
Re: Tying Demo
In Fly Tying by Softhackle
3Jan 6, 2008
by Softhackle
Re: automatic reels
In Gear Talk by TNEAL
2Jul 5, 2014
by Roguerat
Most Recent Posts
Re: Caddis on a zig zag
In General Discussion by TDMunro (Partsman replied)
Re: Fly Tying Vise
In Gear Talk by William99 (DocWet replied)
Re: Rhyacophila betteni group
In Rhyacophila Caddisfly Larva by Creno
Re: This appears to be Dixa sp.
In Dixa True Fly Larva by Creno (Jmd123 replied)
Re: The boys were back in town, Chapter 4 part II
In the Photography Board by Jmd123
Re: The boys were back in town, Chapter 4: new digs, new waters, new fish!
In the Photography Board by Jmd123
Psocodea
In Psocodea Insect Adult by Creno
Rhyacophila hyalinata group
In Rhyacophila vocala Caddisfly Larva by Creno
Re: Don't think it is Gumaga........
In Lepidostoma Little Brown Sedge Larva by Creno (Troutnut replied)
New Instagram account
In Site Updates by Troutnut