Blog & Latest Updates
Fly Fishing Articles
Insects by Common Name
|Ericd||October 1st, 2009, 5:50 pm|
|Hello all. I think I really need help in this category. I try to buy the top-of-the-line brands in the store I happen to be in when I need them, but I still feel like they could be better quality. Case in point, when I tie on a new fly and give the leader a pull to tighten, sometimes, it breaks off at the knot very easily. I haven't broken off fish (read 'caught enough') to make this a huge problem. Should I start ordering all my leaders from Orvis, or somewhere else?|
I also think that I could be cathing more by choosing the right leader for the right condition. I think I understand the importance of length for the season/hatch and a little on the weight of the leader, but perhaps I'm guessing.
I know this is a huge topic. If there are book recommendations too, I'd appreciate it.
Our season just ended, for the most part...
|CaseyP||October 1st, 2009, 6:59 pm|
had the same problem. it always happened at the car as i rushed to get ready to fish. car trunk became littered with half-used spools of tippet and coily "new" leaders that snapped at the knot; i was convinced i had bought shoddy goods.
solved it by making sure to lubricate the knot properly. now as i tighten the knot, i keep the line wet with my lips and tongue the whole way down. then i give it that last tug. works a treat!
as far as what size or type to use, the library will have fly fishing instructional books that will have line/leader/tippet/fly size charts that are helpful. the only hard and fast rule is to use what works for you on your water, though; only way to find that out is to keep fishing and listening to folks in the fly shop.
EDIT FRIDAY MORNING:
Scientific anglers has a chart in the leader packet that tells you what size leader goes (roughly) with what size fly. the tippet size would be the same, methinks. and the basic length for a leader is the length of the rod, i am told.
|"You can observe a lot by watching." Yogi Berra|
|Delablobbo||October 1st, 2009, 7:44 pm|
|Posts: 21||I mostly tie my own leaders. But if I have to pick a knotless at my local flyshop, I always select those at the back of the pile. The ones in front are subject to rot from uv rays.|
|Ericd||October 2nd, 2009, 8:27 am|
|Thanks folks. |
Casey, I do lubricate the normal way and last time out I was even using floatant. I've never heard of matching leader length to rod size. I usually just use long leaders or short ones with a long tippet. That seems like a safe bet, but I don't know. As far as books are concerned, my library does have extensive material on technique, but a lot are poor. I've found quite a bit of poor fly fishing writers out there, or at least ones that I can't relate to. I'm more Gierach than Raines.
William, good idea. My leaders do seem quite brittle sometimes.
|GONZO||October 2nd, 2009, 1:09 pm|
Site Editor"Bear Swamp," PA
As suggested, using old material or improper construction/closure of knots can certainly be factors. However, I'm convinced that the commercial extrusion process used to create knotless leaders inevitably results in a tippet section that does not match the test of equivalent tippet material--regardless of manufacturer. I often use commercial leaders for the butt/hinge section of my trout leaders, but I never trust or use the tippets that are incorporated into them.
Whenever I prepare to replace a butt/hinge section, I start by grasping the last two feet or so (basically the tippet section) of the new leader between my hands and giving it a steady pull. In my experience--at least with most leaders 4X or finer--the tippet will almost always break well below the stated test. I have been doing this for so long that it has become an unnecessary step, but I do it anyway.
After verifying that the strength of the tippet is no better (or worse) than all the other extruded leaders I have used, I cut the tippet section off and attach a fresh tippet of the desired length. The method used to attach the tippet to the leader and the leader to the line is up to you, but a loop-to-loop attachment is probably the most efficient and economical for most applications. Not only does it facilitate quick changes of tippet (or leader, if needed), but the butt/hinge sections generally last for most of the season without being eaten up by tippet changes.
There are a number of interesting older threads about knots and/or leaders on this site. Some of these discuss leader designs and even ideas about matching leaders to line (the "flex test," for example). You might want to do a site search for some of those threads.
I'll add one last note about an aspect of knots/leaders in which I seem to differ from some fly fishers:
For most of my trout fishing, I'm not at all interested in the search for "100%" tippet-to-fly knots. Although I want a knot that reliably retains most of the tippet strength, I also want that knot to be the weakest link in the chain. In my opinion, using 100% tippet-to-fly knots often creates a situation in which the knot that attaches the fly is stronger than the knot that attaches the tippet to the leader. (This is especially true if the leader-to-tippet knot is a blood knot, surgeon's knot/loop, or perfection loop). This often results in a full length of tippet material remaining with the fly after a break. Even if reliable 100% knots could be used for both connections, a break would happen somewhere along the length of the tippet. If any part of my leader has to break, accidentally or on purpose, I want the break to be at the fly.
PS--Floatant on the tippet can cause a knot to slip and should never be used to lubricate knots. Water is probably best for that purpose.
|Martinlf||October 2nd, 2009, 6:55 pm|
|I'm in complete agreement with Gonzo in principle, and differ primarily in the knot used to attach tippet to leader. I've been using a ligature knot for two years, when I have the time and patience to tie it, and I've found it to be, as Art Scheck claims, a very strong way to join tippet to leader. Water is the only lubricant that I know of that works with this knot. When I'm in a hurry, I'll use a triple surgeon's knot. One other thing I've been doing some, especially for nymphing, is to use a tippet ring, attaching it with a Trilene knot. This makes replacing droppers very easy. This spring a guide showed me how to close the Trilene knot without getting a pigtail in the line by pulling on the tag end and the line, after moistening the knot well. I often use a Trilene knot for my fly as well, if I can get both loops through the eye, and have enough leader to waste a bit. John Dunn also has a good fly knot, but I have to relearn it, having forgotten how to tie it. It's a Swisher swirl knot. It's shown on one of Swisher's old videos, and may be on the web. The strongest tippet I know of 5X-8X is Enrico Puglisi's PowerFull. See www.waterstrider.com/fishing-gear.htm and http://rockymtnfly.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=806 [scroll down to the second post]|
|"He spread them a yard and a half. 'And every one that got away is this big.'"|
|Dryfly||October 2nd, 2009, 7:45 pm|
|Geez, All I need is some Rio superstrong and a clinch knot. Surgeons knot for tippet to leader, sometimes a blood knot if I'm feeling fancy.|
One thing I think people don't do enough is replace tippets and leaders and retie knots. Just those two things will reduce the number of lost fish. Sometimes I'll get lazy but it comes back to get you when a top end trout takes your fly and breaks you off immediately. That really stings.
Flourocarbon, Is it worth the money?
|UPTroutBum||October 3rd, 2009, 10:25 am|
|I match my leader length to the size of the river and depth of the water and tippet size to the size of the fly. Key is to make sure everything is smooth, especially with small flies, I use big streamers a lot and it usually doesn't matter much. |
I buy cheaper stuff, but as said above I always lubricate and test my knots well beyond what a normal trout will do. The only fluorocarbon tippet I use is on my 5x tippet.
The strength test I find and funny is when I get a snag and it takes everything I got to pull it free, that is when you know everything is strong.
| " The true fisherman approaches the first day of fishing season with|
all the sense of wonder and awe of a child approaching Christmas." John Voelker
|Softhackle||October 3rd, 2009, 5:22 pm|
Site EditorWellsville, NY
It seems everyone has a different take on leaders. I tie my own using Maxima Leader material, Great stuff! For me leader length is determined by where you fish and water conditions. I have a recipe for a 15 foot and 17 foot leaders. Difficult to purchase these. At any rate, as mentioned keep leaders out of direct sunlight. It supposedly deteriorates leader material.
I like Davy's Knot for tying the fly to the leader. I recently started using leader rings placed between the last section of leader material and the tippet itself. Helps the leader to last longer.
|"I have the highest respect for the skilled wet-fly fisherman, as he has mastered an art of very great difficulty." Edward R. Hewitt|
Flymphs, Soft-hackles and Spiders: http://www.troutnut.com/libstudio/FS&S/index.html
|Lastchance||October 4th, 2009, 4:38 pm|
|Hi: I use a blood knot to attach leader to tippet and a clinch knot for tippet to fly. I attach a dropper with a surgeon's knot. I really never have a problem unless I tie faulty knots. I make my own leaders out of 330 yard spools of Stren mono and various sizes, which will tie tons of leaders very cheaply. I keep the mono in my freezer to keep it fresh. Also, I have used a tippet ring and it certainly does extend the life of your leader. |
My two cents, Bruce
|Oldredbarn||October 5th, 2009, 1:42 pm|
If you are interested in tying your own leaders look in to George Harvey or Charles Ritz, "A Fly Fishers Life", if you can find it. Both these guys have worked out leader formulas for just about any situation.
Sunlight is the enemy of mono...If you leave your vest in the car etc you may run in to trouble when you least wish for it...say the biggest trout of the season. I try to replace my leaders and tippett every season, but you never really know how long it's been sitting around a shop or warehouse. When I buy new I write the date I purchased it somewhere on the label. It would be wonderful if manufactures would do this for us..."Best if used by, etc".
I must admit that I have a small box in the basement full of half used tippett, but the 6x works really well on the ice fishing reel for jigging through the ice. I always have some laying around to give to the nephews when they are practising their knots.
Mel Krieger, may he rest in peace, in his beginning fly vid's would always say "slow but firm" when pulling up the knot. If you pull too quickly you can generate friction/heat that can undermine the material and the knot.
I do something like Gonzo. I sometimes purchase a knotless leader down to 4x. If I'm going smaller than 4x I remove about a foot from the tip (I think there is in the neighborhood of two feet of 4x, in this example, at the end of the leader)and tie on 5x from here. Sometimes I don't even do this but just tie on the 5x etc. This way as you rebuild you will still have some 4x at the end to work with.
I have noticed, again as Gonzo mentioned, that the 4x listed on the knotless leader is thicker than the 4x tippett of the same company. I was told by my fly fishing mentor, when I started, to always use leader and tippet from the same manufacturer...I don't know really that this is a must but I have always stuck with it.
|"Even when my best efforts fail it's a satisfying challenge, and that, after all, is the essence of fly fishing." -Chauncy Lively|
"Envy not the man who lives beside the river, but the man the river flows through." Joseph T Heywood
|Ericd||October 19th, 2009, 4:59 pm|
|Thank you all. I was overwhelmed by the many long responses and put this frustration on the back-burner. The stream season is closed, but I'm trying a new lake for the first time this weekend, so I'll have to do some new reading because lake fishing for trout is new.|
|Bippie||November 26th, 2009, 10:13 am|
|Fly fishing for over 40 years, used to buy tapered leaders but about 25 years ago I started tying my own. I started with a Mason leader kit, through years of trial and error I came up with some designs that work well for me. Now I just buy mono on large spools from Wally World or Kmart, or the sporting goods store.... the cheap stuff, $2 to $4 a spool. I tie a bunch of leaders and give them to a few friends, everybody seems satisfied. For tippet material I tend to buy the better quality name brand stuff.|
As for the knots, any mono knot needs to be lubricated with water/saliva. I use the perfection loop, triple surgeons knot, clinch, turle, barrel knot, etc. When making leaders at home I keep a small container of water handy to lubricate every knot before cinching it tight.
|Lastchance||November 27th, 2009, 12:27 pm|
|I tie my own leaders using bulk spools of Stren mono, which I should have for a life time. They work great and it's much cheaper than buying them. I use blood knots to connect the pieces and a double surgeons knot to add the tippet.|
|Ericd||May 25th, 2010, 5:48 pm|
|I'm back to trying to figure out leaders. I started tying my own with descending tippet weight, mostly because the store bought tapers in my vest disappeared all of a sudden one day on a frustrating pool filled with shy trout. Why should I use mono, or anything else other than tippet material? Cost? |
I have "A Fly Fisher's Life" on order at the local library.
Thanks again for the help folks.
|Re: Double Surgeons Knots Are Breaking|
In General Discussion by Mshumrick
|12||Aug 15, 2017|
|Re: Fly Fishing - Basics, Knots and Techniques|
In Fly Tying by Zakisimo
|2||Dec 24, 2014|
| Fly Fishing - Basics, Knots and Techniques|
In Fly Tying by Zakisimo
In General Discussion by Mntman888
|5||Apr 30, 2015|
|Re: Tippet affecting Energy Transfer?|
In Gear Talk by FisherOfMen
|6||Apr 28, 2015|
|Re: Knots.. Which one??|
In Beginner Help by Bmark0610
|9||May 15, 2015|
|Re: Questions about leaders and tippets|
In Beginner Help by Cptenn94
|8||Apr 30, 2015|
In Gear Talk by Martinlf
|95||Mar 26, 2012|
|Re: Furled leaders|
In Gear Talk by Adirman
|11||Jul 13, 2018|
|Re: Steelhead Report/Leader formula|
In General Discussion by Goose
|4||Oct 7, 2011|
|Most Recent Posts|
|Re: Long-time reader, never-time poster? Start here!|
In General Discussion by Troutnut (Wbranch replied)
|Re: Dubbing wax questions|
In Fly Tying by Brian314 (Wbranch replied)
|Re: Floating line, WF or DT|
In Gear Talk by Red_green_h (Wbranch replied)
|Re: Firehole Dry Fly hooks|
In Fly Tying by Iasgair (TNEAL replied)
| Invitation to the 33rd Slovenian Open Fly Tying Championship 2020|
In General Discussion by Lucky_luke
|Re: Fishing Rod Suggestions|
In Gear Talk by Princemoga (Wbranch replied)
|Re: Little Manistee|
In Fishing Reports by Summer_doug
|Re: Iowa Driftless|
In General Discussion by KevinB (Red_green_h replied)
|Re: Need an excuse to buy new rods|
In Gear Talk by Barbaube (Red_green_h replied)
|Re: Rio Puerco, Northern New Mexico|
In Fishing Reports by Red_green_h