Fly Fishing for Trout Home
User Password
or register.
Scientific name search:

> > Spawning Fish

MartinlfDecember 16th, 2006, 8:29 am
Palmyra PA

Posts: 3233
I have always been a bit fearful about fishing when and where I thought it might be possible to disturb spawning fish. Steve of Flyfisher's Paradise in State College PA suggested the following (my paraphrases): 1: Avoid wading in general as much as possible. 2. Avoid wading in and fishing in gentle gravel filled riffles and tails of pools. 3. Fish to rising fish, which are not spawning. 4. Fish delayed harvest streams, most of which have fewer wild fish.

These tips are helpful, but I'd be interested in others, and any information in general about ways to avoid disturbing spawners. I know browns and brookies spawn in fall, and redds can be disturbed by wading in them up to the time the eggs hatch in early spring. Most wild rainbows I understand are spring spawners, though fall spawning strains have been bred. When do the rainbows eggs hatch? Do they have similar spawning habits to browns and brookies--i.e. does rule 2 apply to them? I'd appreciate any information on this topic.
"He spread them a yard and a half. 'And every one that got away is this big.'"

--Fred Chappell
TroutnutDecember 17th, 2006, 8:30 am
Bellevue, WA

Posts: 2737
I've never been convinced that disturbing spawning fish actually harms the population. That seems to be one of those things about which some conservation-minded anglers worry themselves too much, and those worries are reinforced by the antiquated idea of closed seasons.

I doubt that a fish disturbed while spawning (spooked or caught) will not eventually resume and finish its job. If it's fatally injured or kept, of course, it won't spawn, but the effect of that is no different from that of killing the same fish at any other time of the year. Half the fish disturbed will be males, anyway, and I'm pretty sure if one of them is taken out of action another will happily replace him.

As far as egg survival goes, I'm pretty sure that the influence of angler foot traffic is dwarfed by routine fluctuations in factors like water level, water temperature, dissolved oxygen, substrate quality, sediment shifting, etc. It would be next to impossible to put a number on it, but if we did I bet it would be several digits past the decimal point.

And I think in most cases the fluctuations in egg survival don't matter much, because the adult spawners produce more fry than can be supported as adults or even juveniles by the stream's habitat and food supply. I don't know what the typical number of eggs per mile would be exactly, but it seems like it would usually be in the tens of thousands to millions, whereas the number of adults the stream can support is usually in the hundreds or very low thousands per mile. It's like filling a jar with jelly beans: if the jar can only hold 500 beans, it doesn't matter if you start out with 20,000 beans or 20,100 beans: you're still only going to fit 500.

If the population is very low, then egg production might indeed be a bottleneck, but if there are so few fish it's that much less likely that you'll accidentally step on the eggs. Unless you like dancing on gravel bars in a bull trout stream, I doubt this is a very common scenario.

I'm not saying to be reckless -- it's just common sense to try not to stomp around in the redds. But almost anything we do in the stream can have some negative influence. For example, every step you take in the spring might squish several nymphs between the rocks, robbing the trout of how many eventual meals? And how much beneficial vegetation might you accidentally uproot when you have to wade through a patch of it? There are all kinds of small harms we might inflict, yet none of them keep us off the stream because their effects are so minor. I just don't see why this should be any different.

Perhaps DMM can correct me if there are any studies showing that angler activity during spawning causes statistically significant damage to the population. I haven't heard of any.
Jason Neuswanger, Ph.D.
Troutnut and salmonid ecologist
MartinlfDecember 17th, 2006, 10:07 am
Palmyra PA

Posts: 3233
I find both David and Jason's observations interesting, and again we are in the realm of needing some controlled studies which may not be forthcoming. Several shop owners I know of have counseled caution in regard to fishing when fish are spawning, while a Pennsylvania Fish Commission biologist I once talked with about this took the same position Jason did in his post. Recently I fished a rainbow stream, assuming that the fish were probably spring spawners, and, along with my more knowledgeable fishing partner, checking the bottom to be sure we didn't step into any redds. I have no fear that we caused any problems, and I'm sometimes willing to carefully fish wild brown trout streams in the winter following the first three guidelines listed in my first post recommended by Steve Sywensky. I've always wished to err on the side of caution, but I sometimes do wonder if I am being overly cautious--or not cautious enough. I look forward to David's reply, and others' well-reasoned information on this topic.
"He spread them a yard and a half. 'And every one that got away is this big.'"

--Fred Chappell
Shawnny3December 20th, 2006, 3:08 pm
Pleasant Gap, PA

Posts: 1197
Wow. You guys are amazing. Again: Wow.

Jewelry-Quality Artistic Salmon Flies, by Shawn Davis
TroutnutDecember 20th, 2006, 4:39 pm
Bellevue, WA

Posts: 2737
Lots of good points David, and a few I would take issue with too. Unfortunately I'm frantically packing for the holidays so I won't have time to coherently organize my rebuttal for a while!
Jason Neuswanger, Ph.D.
Troutnut and salmonid ecologist
Upnorth2December 20th, 2006, 9:48 pm

Posts: 62

I lived on the West Coast for awhile and wondered by the coho seemed to decline over a period of time. Was unaware of the studies you referred to so thanks for clearing some things up in your post. I always thought that the Seattle hoards had to have some kind of affect.

Quick Reply

You have to be logged in to post on the forum. It's this easy:
Username:          Email:

Password:    Confirm Password:

I am at least 13 years old and agree to the rules.

Related Discussions

TitleRepliesLast Reply
Re: Flooding Effects?
In General Discussion by Jesse
8Feb 15, 2012
by Jesse
Re: Had some great silver salmon fishing
In Site Updates by Troutnut
13Feb 19, 2013
by Wbranch
Re: STILL no steelhead...but the brownies were biting!
(1 more)

In the Photography Board by Jmd123
7Apr 2, 2022
by Jmd123
Re: Fly fishing in November in Very northern NY
In General Discussion by KeithZ
6Nov 16, 2015
by PaulRoberts
Re: Spawning Steel Head
In the Photography Board by JAD
7Nov 4, 2009
by Martinlf
Re: What do you think?
In General Discussion by Falsifly
3Mar 6, 2013
by Crepuscular
Re: Tiny Stoneflies?
In the Identify This! Board by Pryal74
13Mar 23, 2012
by Entoman
Re: Mayfly and Stonefly Parasites
In the Identify This! Board by Willmilne
1Jan 25, 2010
by Konchu
Re: Prince William Sound Bear Hunt -- finally, success!
In Site Updates by Troutnut
8Jun 16, 2013
by PaulRoberts