Troutnut.com Fly Fishing for Trout Home
User Password
or register.
Scientific name search:

> > Wow, they really can take forever to get off the water, Page 2

This topic is about the Mayfly Species Ephemerella dorothea dorothea

Ephemerella dorothea consists of two subspecies (Subspecies: Entomologists sometimes further divide a species into distinct groups called subspecies, which have two lower-case words on the end of their scientific name instead of one. The latter is the sub-species name. For example, Maccaffertium mexicanum mexicanum and Maccaffertium mexicanum integrum are two different subspecies of Maccaffertium mexicanum.), which both produce excellent action. Ephemerella dorothea dorothea is a small species of Sulphur in the East, and Ephemerella dorothea infrequens (formerly Ephemerella infrequens) is one of the two main Pale Morning Dun hatches of the West. The remainder of this page focuses on the dorothea dorothea subspecies (Subspecies: Entomologists sometimes further divide a species into distinct groups called subspecies, which have two lower-case words on the end of their scientific name instead of one. The latter is the sub-species name. For example, Maccaffertium mexicanum mexicanum and Maccaffertium mexicanum integrum are two different subspecies of Maccaffertium mexicanum.), and Ephemerella dorothea infrequens is discussed separately on its own page.

This is one of the most challenging mayfly hatches on Eastern waters. On many streams, it follows or overlaps hatches of the larger, lingering Ephemerella invaria. Read more...

The Discussion

KonchuAugust 12th, 2007, 9:09 am
Site Editor
Indiana

Posts: 498
I think that the invaria/rotunda problem is really interesting; it certainly caught my attention as a graduate student. It is a a topic that has permeated several discussion threads here. I'd like to make a summary of all the comments at some point, but not today. I look forward to some open-minded, constructive dialog that perhaps can lead to these problems being sorted out in a formal way.
GeneAugust 12th, 2007, 10:48 pm
Posts: 107Gentlemen:

Thank you for your words however, I wasn't really defending myself. I just wanted to make sure that everyone knew I usually follow the standard procedure of always getting another expert's analysis and opinion especially on identification. Most people in the field do this. Also, I don't want people to think that anyone including myself is always right on anything especially on arbitrary things such as classification etc. I appreciate all the work that goes into this site and god knows this is a labor of love and you don't make much money with such a venture. I know because I have a number of sites for the love of fly fishing and aquatic entomology too. Another point on taxonomy and classification: I once sent the same 4 Stenonemas (now classified as Stenacron) to 4 different universities who were the tops in aquatic entomology. I got back 4 different identifications to species! Nature doesn't classify..but man does. But it's fun to do this stuff especially when they may mean something more important in water quality studies.

As far as the sulfurs go it will be interesting to see what happens over time (like in the next 5 years or so) because of global warming in freestone streams. For example, I was at Big Pine 6 weeks ago and it was in terrible shape. The stream doesn't hold (or receive) the water it once did and the temperature kept going into the 80's. What will this mean? I think that some species will start to disappear because they prefer colder water. We have a standard in the spring creeks of PA because of their constant temperature regime (46-50). This limits diversity but gives us large populations of a few mayflies, like the sulfurs. The freestone streams nearby also contain sulfurs but not in the quantity or do these streams usually have the long emergence period pattern of the spring creeks. E. invaria or rotunda whatever you call it is a very unique nymph. Why? Because it's only requirement is high oxygen. It is what I call a Superior Biological Indicator. It can live in just about any type of water from riffles to pools and on any substrate. Because of these factors when these mayflies start to disappear it means that there are usually serious problems in the stream. Many aquatic larvae are substrate specific so you can't really use them the way you would like. It will be interesting to see if other sulfur species move in for E. invaria.

I would invite all people who frequent this forum who have these flies in their streams to keep a close eye on their populations and patterns. They may serve as the best metric of what is really happening in our streams in the future.

As far as their coloration goes this is usually related to pH. If the stream is more alkaline the flies tend to be lighter colors in the wings especially. In waters below pH 7 and other's which are slightly acidic 6 to 7 these mayflies will have darker wings in the dun stage and may exhibit other color changes in the bodies and legs as well. This is a pretty good rule of thumb and works for most mayflies. For example, the Green Drakes from Kettle Creek are heavily colored on the wings as compared to the same species on Penns Creek due to pH differences. The Hendricksons on Kettle have almost black wings compared to the Hendricksons which still come off in small quantities on the Breeches which are light grey.

As far as emergence patterns go the sulfurs exhibit a number of different patterns dependent on the environmental conditions including wind, and temperature of the water and humidity. I've always thought the easiest trout fishing days occurred when they emerged quickly because the trout couldn't get that selective. But when you have high moisture and the duns ride the water long periods of time to dry their wings the fish get real smart real fast. On the spring creeks by the time the flies have emerged for a month or so the fish get so super selective many fly anglers wait till after dark to get any success.

Finally I have a theory which has little scientific merit to it but perhaps has just enough to make it hang around in my head. I actually believe that in many streams all 3 species of suflurs were present at one time. Over time the species evolved into one species and retains certain morphological characteristics and size graduations of all 3 species. Why do I say this because on Falling Spring the early sulfurs years ago were around size 12 and you might mistake them for Hendricksons. As the season progressed then characteristics and color patterns of routnda and dorothea appear. What gives me some weird reason to keep this theory around is this: spine patterns on the genitalia started with a certain small number like subvaria and increases as the year progresses like rotunda and invaria!

Of course, this would then lead one to believe if they could reproduce were they really separate species or maybe subspecies? Don't know but color wise and even morphologically these flies fit this! I have also seen this in other mayflies also including Stenonema and Stenacron. That's why it would be interesting to run DNA analysis on old samples going back 50 to 60 years that universities and museums had as their type specimens.

One other thing about sulfurs that I have noticed in the last 10 years is that the bright hot days cause them to emerge later and later in the day and into the night. That's why many hatch charts are so far off. They appear to like clouds more than the bright sun even on spring creeks. This is also true of spinner returns for these species which I have seen at 3:00 in the morning when temps cool down. I always wanted to ask my friend Ernie Schwiebert about this but his untimely death has left a real hole in the fly fishing world. He really had a detailed mind and he could probably comment on this from all the streams he had fished.

tight lines and big trout that rise

gene macri
WiflyfisherAugust 13th, 2007, 5:19 am
Wisconsin

Posts: 628
When did DNA analysis start being used and is it absolutely accurate for identifying insects?

Gene, do you have a guess at what is the optimal temperature for E. invaria/rotunda to emerge?
John S.
https://WiFlyFisher.com
MartinlfAugust 13th, 2007, 1:10 pm
Moderator
Palmyra PA

Posts: 3056
Great stuff, Gene. I especially found the comments on color interesting.
"He spread them a yard and a half. 'And every one that got away is this big.'"

--Fred Chappell
GeneAugust 13th, 2007, 10:30 pm
Posts: 107Gentlemen:

I think the that DNA species recognition will need to be done in the future if it hasn't already started in aquatic entomology. If you read the books you would think that this is cut and dried but it's not. The universities with the most power usually control the classification system in my estimation. There are exceptions. Identification and classification has always been a problem with mayflies for one reason: Biology of Mayflies by Needham, Traver, and Hsu which was from the 1930's I believe. Why? Because Needham was a fly fisherman. Look at the descriptions of those insects! I have never ever found such a delineation of detail for any other group of insects! Color was very important back then and it remains so today ...even if it may blind us to other things! There has always been a holy alliance between aquatic entomology and fly fishing!

As far as the specific temperature for emerging sulfurs I believe that there are a ton of variables here. Spring creeks are different from freestone streams sometimes. In a spring creek everything is controlled by sunlight because the stream has a constant temperature regime. So it's 46-50 degrees the entire year. This makes for a number of strange things happening that we'll discuss at another time including multiple generations etc. In freestone streams the number of days the stream is at certain temperature will mature the nymph (hormones in the insect) and then they will emerge. However, I have noticed that since the days have gotten much brighter the insects will emerge when there is more cloud cover in most situations. They also emerge later in the day or earlier in the mornings. I believe the hatching cycle is screwed up on many streams due to the increased warming.

On Falling Spring and most limestone spring creeks in PA. the sulfurs would emerge in two ways: 1) they would be sporadic here and there; which is not that good because there might not be enough ofa hatch to get most of the fish to rise and 2) they would emerge in a normal hatch pattern with most of the flies emerging during a time period. What happened on the spring creeks is that the hatch would start in the early afternoon in the early part of the season and then get later and later. But now the sulfur hatches ( and many others too) are usually emerging in the late afternoon into the evenings on many streams even in the early season. It's because we don't really have a spring season anymore. The streams (freestone) may get warm very quickly especially with lower water conditions and mayflies emerge later in the day and evening. This never really occurred before and you can check old fishing articles and books from the 50's and 60's by many authors and they will tell you when the flies hatched and they all weren't in the late afternoon or evening!

tight lines and rising trout


gene

MartinlfAugust 14th, 2007, 9:56 am
Moderator
Palmyra PA

Posts: 3056
Gene, and others, I just watched An Inconvenient Truth, the movie about global warming. I strongly recommend it to anyone who cares about trout, mayflies, and the planet as a whole.
"He spread them a yard and a half. 'And every one that got away is this big.'"

--Fred Chappell
Shawnny3August 14th, 2007, 11:02 am
Moderator
Pleasant Gap, PA

Posts: 1197
Wow. I think I just learned more about mayflies in the last 15 minutes of reading than I have in the rest of my life. Thank you, Gene, for your expertise - you are most welcome to keep making my head spin.

Louis, I also saw 'An Inconvenient Truth', and my initial impression of it was very much like yours. Since then I've delved deeper into the subject, though, and I've become quite skeptical of a lot of Gore's claims. While I'm no expert on global warming, I can understand scientific arguments pretty well, but this issue is so politicized that I'm not even sure the scientific arguments can be separated from the political ones. When we have politicians making documentaries about scientific phenomena, we ought to be alarmed, and I don't mean alarmed in the way Gore intends. You know what? I'd hate to muddy this thread with this discussion, but it's a very important one to flyfishers and entomologists, so let's start up a new one. I'll do the honors.

-Shawn
Jewelry-Quality Artistic Salmon Flies, by Shawn Davis
www.davisflydesigns.com
WiflyfisherAugust 14th, 2007, 12:15 pm
Wisconsin

Posts: 628
Gene, you mention you feel the insects on freestone streams are happening either much earlier in the day or much later in the day. Do you also feel the mayfly hatches you study are occurring many days ahead of when they use to begin?

Thanks for your time.

John S.
https://WiFlyFisher.com
GeneAugust 14th, 2007, 12:36 pm
Posts: 107Gentlemen:

Gore is right on one thing we are getting warmer. I haven't seen the movie. I have a problem with Gore and Robert Kennedy JR. doing this type of stuff because they aren't scientists and they make a lots of mistakes especially Kennedy Jr. which we'll also save for another day.

Gore is wrong on his carbon trading idea however because it won't work. In fact, some people in the scientific community refer to this idea as "cancer bonds" because it will overload certain areas with a great number of air pollutants. None of this averaging carbon trading stuff will work in the real world because it's just too hard to model and realize that these chemicals and pollutants have synergistic and cumulative effects in the atmosphere. As a write this the idiots in Harrisburg PA.-- the DEP is ready to permit an asphalt plant .8 of mile upwind of an elementary school. The county already has some of the worst air pollution in the state. The synergistic and cumulative effects aren't calculated in their model...which is a model not real world data since no one actually measures what comes out of these plants.

If we had proper records going back for the last 70 years of mayflies in streams in the Northeast it might really show us some interesting data of what is occurring in terms of climate and environmental degradation. We might be able to search univ. records and other places and chart or graph the data for an eye opening of what these streams were really like.

I am probably the greatest proponent of benchmarking and establishing scientific baselines of streams biologically and chemically. This is a time consuming labor intensive process but it is the only method that works in protecting them. Because of the data I had accumulated over the years in these arenas Dr. Black and I with help from fly anglers and citizens were able to shut down Big Spring hatchery. The stream is now in great shape with the mayflies and other insects returning. If we are going to save what we have left of our waters benchmarking and baselining must be done.

tight lines and rising trout and please will someone go find a friendly Indian and do a rain dance over PA.......

gene


GeneAugust 14th, 2007, 1:01 pm
Posts: 107Gentlemen:

Yes, on many waters mayfly and other hatches are occurring earlier due to the temps. What is happening in many parts of Pennsylvania is that you are getting the hatches overlapping. For instance, you aren't getting the normal progression of hatches that you read about in your books and hatch charts. Let me give just a quick example of how the fly hatches were in N. PA when I was young and fished places like Kettle Creek, Cross Forks, Hamersly and other streams of that nature.

You would get your early stone, early blue quill (Paraleptophlebia)early black caddis (Chimarra or Microsema) then a few weeks later you would get Hendricksons (Ephemerella subvaria) and Quill Gordons (Eperous), then the Grannom Caddis ...and then little later you start getting some sulfurs and march browns....etc

This was true for many parts of PA. Now you might get all these hatches which used to take from the end of March---May compressed into a couple of months with a bunch of stuff coming off in a 3-4 week period. You do get the spread you use to get; a few will emerge here and there but you are not getting your normal patterns do to the environmental changes.

I'm sure you have heard from fly anglers in the last few years that many of the hatches are "petering" out! I was at Yellow Creek in Bedford County at the tail end of the Drake hatch this year. I slept in my van next to a section of the creek called the Narrows. There was little action and the water was over 73 degrees at 7:15 p.m. I stayed til 9:00 and few flies of any species really did much except for some midges.

I got up around 3:30 to take a leak (this always happens when you drink beer before you go to bed) and decided to take a look at the water. There were tons of sulfur spinners and a few drake spinners and tons of March browns. The air and water evidently weren't right for these flies til the middle of the night. There were also some sulfur duns popping.

I am starting to see this phenomenon more and more. There is a way to find out if this is happening and that's by using a blacklight trap on the stream. I think I still have one that's battery operated. Next season I'm going to try it out and see what it happening on these streams all nite. Because you can find the nymphs in the water but few anglers are noticing the hatches they once did. There is only one answer and that is many species are adapting to the environmental conditions and emerging more in the night than they did years ago.

I would be interested to hear from anglers who have had similar experiences. I have always fished at night but there appears to more of this going on in different streams than ever before.

tight lines and rising trout

gene
WiflyfisherAugust 15th, 2007, 1:36 pm
Wisconsin

Posts: 628
using a blacklight trap on the stream

Gene what is a "blacklight trap"?
John S.
https://WiFlyFisher.com
GeneAugust 15th, 2007, 2:41 pm
Posts: 107A black light trap is nothing more than a black light...(I don't know if they use that stuff in college anymore)in a double bucket sort of rig. The bottom of the bucket usually has some type of alcohol or something to kill the insects which are attracted to the light. Here's a good link to what I am describing:

http://www.esg.montana.edu/aim/methods/blt.html

They usually work fairly well and it's how I was one of the first to discover year ago how trico males came off at night. It also allows you to find out what's emerging at night that you may not see in the day as well as returning insects.

tight lines and rising trout
WiflyfisherAugust 15th, 2007, 3:19 pm
Wisconsin

Posts: 628
I love that idea!!!

I often thought about designing some sort of underwater funnel trap. The trap would allow water to pass through but would trap emerging insects (along with some debris). I was evening thinking about those sticky strips for catching flies and shining a light on it. But you would not be able to easily remove the insects from the sticky strip.

Some sort of trap just seems to me to be a smarter way to collect insects than splashing around in the water with a big bug net.

The nightlight idea really seems to be great way of collecting insects. Especially, if you have a screen to stop unwanted things from get caught. Next year I will have to see if the WDNR will allow me to try that.

Thanks!!
John S.
https://WiFlyFisher.com
SGS126EJune 13th, 2008, 8:19 am
Putnam County NY

Posts: 1
Tough hatch to fish. I spend most of June evenings on the East Branch of the Croton River. After 30 odd years it's still a challenge,and I look forward to it every year. Early in evening the browns take emergers and the presentation has to be perfect. I have visually followed the drift of duns over feeding fish and rarely are they taken. Around 8:30 the spinners trigger a feeding frenzy with rainbows as the most active. By this time visibility is down to 0 and anything less than a perfect presentation will be refused; and one imperfect drift will put the fish down. The best lesson to fish this hatch is taken from the book of the Marine Corps sniper, "One Shot, one kill." Short drifts, less line on the water means you have move to move to positions advantageous to get the best drift. Don't know how it is in Alaska or Colorado, but these are New York fish and they have to be mugged.
FalsiflyJune 14th, 2008, 8:09 am
Hayward, WI.

Posts: 660

Don't know how it is in Alaska or Colorado, but these are New York fish and they have to be mugged.





Welcome SGS126E,
I had heard that NY leads the country in muggings, obviously a lot of destitute people out that way. But to think that fly fishermen have joined the ranks of the despicable, stooping so low as to mug a trout, boggles the imagination. Yes, times must be tough. I havenít fished Alaska, but I have fished Colorado and there were times when I had to beg, I even did a little pan handling along the Frying Pan, but I have never had to resort to mugging. I hope that all of your fishing is done after dark to minimize the possibility of a witness or is it so bad that you commit the crime in broad daylight? I hope this trend doesnít spread south and criminalize my PA friends. Anyway, I love the above quote and couldnít resist a sarcastic reply. I hope all is taken in the jestful spirit intended.




Falsifly
When asked what I just caught that monster on I showed him. He put on his magnifiers and said, "I can't believe they can see that."
GONZOJune 14th, 2008, 2:17 pm
Site Editor
"Bear Swamp," PA

Posts: 1681
I hope this trend doesn't spread south and criminalize my PA friends.

Sorry, Falsifly, but I'm afraid that I would have to plead guilty (with extenuating circumstances). As a lifelong resident of what I lovingly call Pressured America (PA), I can attest that the practice of trout-mugging is widespread here. However, I think the case for insanity can be made. As further extenuation, many of us practice the version known as "mug-and-release." This, I hope, should reduce the criminal penalties to that of a misdemeanor, or perhaps criminal mischief.
FalsiflyJune 15th, 2008, 8:49 am
Hayward, WI.

Posts: 660
Well that certainly explains why the Eastern trout are so difficult to catch, and proves that trout possess at least some intelligence. After repeated subjection to mugging its no wonder these fish have acquired a defense mechanism. And, further proves that the eastern fly fisherman is indeed insane. One might postulate that the street muggings are committed by ex fly fishermen that have moved on to easier prey. The Western Civilization (all that west of PA) on the other hand, has long ago learned that the proper treatment of trout is mutually conducive to a harmonic coexistence that results in a free exchange of give and take.
Falsifly
When asked what I just caught that monster on I showed him. He put on his magnifiers and said, "I can't believe they can see that."
Page:12

Quick Reply

You have to be logged in to post on the forum. It's this easy:
Username:          Email:

Password:    Confirm Password:

I am at least 13 years old and agree to the rules.

Related Discussions

TitleRepliesLast Reply
Re: Little J
In General Discussion by Wbranch
3May 17, 2009
by GONZO
Re: Basic Cranefly Pattern
In Fly Tying by Goose
1May 27, 2011
by Goose
Re: tricos 4pm
In the Mayfly Genus Tricorythodes by IEatimago
8Sep 3, 2007
by Gene
Re: Spring Creek ID
In the Identify This! Board by DOS
3Mar 17, 2009
by DOS
Ephemerella dorothea dorothea (PED)
In the Identify This! Board by Wiflyfisher
0
Re: What do you think?
In General Discussion by Falsifly
3Mar 6, 2013
by Crepuscular
Re: Is it wrong that I can't wait for the fall stockies to return
In General Discussion by Ditch
1Sep 14, 2010
by SlateDrake9
Re: Michigan DNR Fisheries Reports & Publications Library
In General Discussion by TimCat
4Sep 4, 2015
by PaulRoberts
Re: Cinygma mayflies
In the Mayfly Genus Cinygma by Bnewell
2Jul 20, 2011
by Entoman
Re: Question about sulphurs in PA
In General Discussion by Lam
6Apr 28, 2019
by Martinlf
Most Recent Posts
Re: Fall ISO's - Au Sable
In General Discussion by Brian314 (Partsman replied)
Tippet for Doug
In Gear Talk by Martinlf
Re: TMC 518 size 32 hooks
In Fly Tying by Dbarr15 (Martinlf replied)
Re: some fish taken on a modern streamer
In Fishing Reports by Partsman (Jmd123 replied)
Re: traditional streamers- still in use?
In General Discussion by Roguerat (Wbranch replied)
Re: fall colors
In Fishing Reports by Partsman (Wbranch replied)
Re: Emerald shiner steehead
In the Photography Board by Wbranch
Re: Emerald shiners
In General Discussion by Wbranch