Troutnut Forum > Fly Fishing Discussion > Not so Catch and Release, Page 2
| Mtskibum | January 18th, 2008, 8:05 pm | |
| Montana Posts: 25 | I only kept trout once last year. They were wild fish, but i kept them to actually try and thin the fish out, its a fishery only a couple people fish. I kept enough 16-18" browns to smoke a handfull of fillets. I would recomend smoking trout as the best way to cook it. Usually i fish a couple weekends a year on the upper bighorn river. Around 60-100 miles above the resevior that cools the water down for the trout. It is a superb walley and catfish fishery, and because the water is cooler than most catfish waters, we get good tasting cats. I know lots of people know about the trout stretch, but the walley stretch can be just as fun, and every year my entire family pounds the hell out of it to fish for eating fish. The largest walleys hit 4-5 pounds in the river. And we can have good days on the water and catch 20 of them. You would be alot happier with walleyes in your freezer than you would with fresh trout. Do you guys have whitefish in PA? They are superb to smoke up as well. Supposedly the best tasting smoked fresh water fish. I know out here on some trout rivers they are plentiful. | |
|
These advertisements will disappear if you register. | ||
| Wbranch | January 21st, 2008, 12:48 pm | |
| Starlight PA Posts: 230 | Skibum, We have no river whities like out in the West but I've been told there are whitefish (maybe another genus) in some deep cold water lakes and the Great Lakes. It is funny how lots of guys condemn whitefish when they catch them out West. Admittedly if you are from the East and have planned a trip all year it is no fun to just catch whitefish. On the other hand if the trout are off for a day or you want a couple of hours of fun all you need do is find a good riffle on the Madison and put on a couple of nymphs and BB's and you'll soon be into lots of 14" - 18" whities. | |
| West Branch & main stem fly fisher for forty-two years. | ||
| Mcjames | January 22nd, 2008, 2:40 pm | |
| Cortland Manor, NY Posts: 77 | Ha that is funny Wbranch! My one and only time in Montana, I was on the Gallitin River in March in the middle of a snowstorm. I had hooked and lost 3 fish, my toes were numb, and I was tired of knocking the ice off my guides. But I promised myself I would stick it out until I landed one. The next one I hooked, I played it very carefully, backing all the way up into the shallows. Of course, it was a whitefish. Which meant I had to stay out another hour until I finally landed a trout. But on the way home I was reading the little book they give you with your license, and I was fascinated by all the native species I had never heard of-- like burbot. So now I kind of glad I caught a species I won't ever see out East. | |
| I am haunted by waters | ||
| Wbranch | January 23rd, 2008, 10:45 am | |
| Starlight PA Posts: 230 | In Eastern Montana, in some of the tailwaters of the Missouri, there can be found the paddlefish (Polyodon Spathula)which is a very unusual speicies. See link. It seems a shame to kill these fish unless there are so many of them that harvesting some won't degrade the fishery. http://www.glendivechamber.com/pfish.htm (The image file this user tried to include was not found.) | |
| West Branch & main stem fly fisher for forty-two years. | ||
| Andyg | February 24th, 2008, 6:59 pm | |
| Eastern Sussex co., NJ Posts: 12 | Paddlefish are usually caught by snagging with weighted treble hooks! You can see the hook scar on one of those fish. My philosophy is that every fish removed from a body of water is a fish that will never spawn again. Unless a stream or lake is stocked on a regular basis and managed as put and take, successful spawning is absolutely necessary to maintain a good wild fishery; especially with today's fishing pressure. A bad spawning year or two can literally turn a wild fishery around. I like to catch lots of quality fish so I believe in catch-and-release, which is also the best cure for freezer burn! I have yet to encounter a body of water with so many fish that they were stunted. However, in that case culling the population is what a fish and game department would probably recommend. | |
| Mtskibum | February 25th, 2008, 8:22 pm | |
| Montana Posts: 25 | They manage the paddlefish population extremely well, I believe the last couple years have even been record harvests, even though we have been in a drought. And that is with keeping the amount of fish alive to spawn. They will close fishing down immediately once a strict harvest total is reached as well, and they keep good records of the number of paddlefish alive. Montana is one of a handful of states where we have enough paddlefish to fish for them. Fishing for paddlefish or Sturgeon does not interest me however, its a lot of time spent hoping to get lucky. | |
New features!
